Turn It Down? – WhizzTalk

Elizabeth

Blog entry on my website
01/07/2004
social impact, society, music, health

A look at the impact of audio amplication technologies on hearing loss.

July 2004 – Go to a gig or a club these days and you are bound to see people with earplugs in their ears.

Indeed, at an event at San Francisco’s Avalon Ballroom back in April, employees of the nightclub were actually handing out earplugs en masse.

The gig — an appearance by electronic noise-master Squarepusher — marked the west coast premiere of a new sound system provided by UK company Opus Audio.

Opus Audio claims its kit ushers in a new era of crystal clear amplification that aims to transport the high-fidelity reproduction we enjoy from our home stereos to the larger music venues where today’s systems distort the sound.

The sound was undoubtedly unusually clear that night. But it was also excruciatingly loud and much of the audience sought relief by wedging foam plugs in their lugholes.

So why, instead of handing out earplugs, did club management not solve the problem at its origin and turn down the volume?

Let’s jump to an analogous situation for a second. Have you ever called someone on their mobile phone only for them to answer in a harried manner by saying that they are too busy to talk?

An intelligent use of the technology would be to let the call go to voicemail and conduct the conversation at a more convenient moment.

Just because the phone is with you all the time doesn’t mean that you have to answer it all the time. This will become second nature to those generations to come. So much new technology surrounds us at this juncture of human development that we haven’t quite worked out how to use it intelligently.

But where the voicemail analogy is annoying, the clubbing example has more serious ramifications. UK charity for the deaf and hard of hearing, the RNID, has for the past year, conducted an educational campaign (www.dontlosethemusic.com) to try to get clubbers, musicians and people using personal stereos to protect their hearing.

The UK charity put out research back in April 2004 stating that three out of four people who frequently go to clubs and concerts risk damaging their hearing for life. This is signified by the fact that they regularly experience ringing in their ears and dullness of hearing after a night out.

While the sensation only lasts for a short time, if it happens too many times the damage becomes permanent.

The RNID puts forward a rule of thumb that states that if the music prevents you from talking to people about two metres away without shouting, then you’re in a dangerous noise environment.

This is a sobering thought when we’ve all been in clubs, at outdoor concerts, even restaurants, where you can’t hear what someone is saying from a foot away.

The RNID and other groups such as H.E.A.R. (www.hearnet.com) suggest that people in these venues should keep away from the speakers, that they take regular breaks in other rooms, and they avoid exhaustion and dehydration, both of which increase the risk of hearing loss.

These groups emphasise the use of earplugs. “We need to get to a stage where remembering to take your earplugs out with you is as commonplace as remembering safe sex protection,” said Brian Dow, joint head of campaigns at the RNID, in a press release. “If we don’t, we are roller coasting towards an epidemic of premature hearing loss in middle age.”

For sure this is a quick way of preventing people from losing their hearing. But why not just turn it down? Especially when being sensible is hardly the first thing you want to think about when you’re letting off steam on the dancefloor. Anyway calling for them to turn it up is a sign of a truly hardcore punter in the clubber’s lexicon.

To be fair, the RNID does ask that club owners to think carefully about the placement of their speakers, to ensure chill-out space is available away from the dance floor, and to encourage DJs to get involved in the issue.

Unfortunately the Avalon Ballroom did not return calls for comment so we’ll never know why it was happy to damage people’s ears and charge them for the experience that night.

Representatives from San Francisco clubbing institution The Endup were more forthcoming. Markus Barsanti is part of the management team at the club.

He wasn’t altogether dismissive of turning the volume down. “It could be done over time,” he said. “We could gradually step it down but if we automatically turn down the volume people wouldn’t like it.”

Barsanti reported that Endup customers occasionally ask for the music to be turned down and earplugs are available behind the bar for those customers who want them. All staff members on, or adjacent to, the dance floor wear earplugs. Endup staff occasionally complains of excessive volume, he said, but this is often when the club isn’t busy.

“The DJs don’t realise that it is much louder on the dance floor when the club is not at its fullest,” he observed. “[Sometimes] it gets so loud in the DJ booth that the DJ doesn’t hear what is happening.”

While he accepted that club proprietors have a role to play, Barsanti placed some responsibility with individuals themselves. “It is like drinking too much,” he commented. “Just as we hope you’ll make the best judgment and drink some water when you’re too drunk, in most clubs there is that option to go somewhere where it is not so loud.”

He added that the Endup has a spacious patio for this very purpose.

What about more modern sound systems that envelope the listener in luxurious sound without damaging his or her ears?

Jodie Brown, an engineer with Opus Audio, was frustrated when told of the situation at the Avalon Ballroom that night. “It shouldn’t have been painful if run right,” he said.

Opus Audio has spent the last ten years working to fill music venues with a sound that is clear and powerful but not distorted and loud.

But it seems that working practices prevent this aim from being recognised. “With lots of live acts the venue is bound by contract to let someone else engineer the show,” explained Scot Collinson, U.S. distributor for Opus Audio. “That engineer may have been on the road for a month or so and their ears are maybe not as sensitive as someone walking in to the venue for the first time.”

Great. So we’re all being deafened because the sound engineer is deaf?

But this is not a new issue. There are generations of sound engineers and rock musicians have been complaining of hearing loss for decades.

While they may be exposed to it more than your regular punter who hits the nightlife once a week, there is still something wrong with our logic.

For instance, San Francisco city ordinances regulate how loud the music is outside the venue but there is nothing governing what is happening inside on the dance floor.

Media and moralist attention always focuses on the use of drugs in these venues. Ten years from now we might find that the most dangerous legacy of club culture is something much less salacious: the music itself.